Johnny is joined in the "You Can't Pretend" video by an all-star cast of family and friends, including Shane Lawlor, Christopher Leigh (from Electric Touch), Suzanna Choffell, Dustin Welch, Benjamin Hotchkiss (from The Real Heroes), Michael Kingcaid (from What Made Milwaukee Famous), Alexandra Valenti, Emily and Meagan Antonetti, Gabi Tuschak, and MoGreen.